Choosing Custom on the report builder and then clearing or retyping one of the dates left the report showing whatever it had last worked out, under dates that no longer matched it. A date box reports every value you pass through while typing, so a half-finished date was being treated as a real one.
The builder now waits until both dates are complete and in order, and says so rather than leaving stale numbers on screen. A range that runs backwards is treated the same way.